New Owners, Same Original Recipe

Take-out, Delivery, Dine in

Contact us for all of your catering needs.
Graduations, Birthdays, Communions, and more.

What's on the menu

Michael's Pastaria is your locally owned & operated neighborhood pizzeria located in Nutley, N.J. Under new ownership with the original recipes you love and trust. Browse our menu online or stop in today to try one of our specials.

Michael's Famous Thin Crust Pizza

PLAIN 16.95

PLAIN 12.00

PLAIN 16.95

Processed with VSCOcam with a6 preset


$12.50 - $18.50

Fresh plum tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.


Meat Lovers

$14.95 - $21.50

Sausage, meatball, pepperoni, and ham.




Michael's famous meatballs. Ricotta cheese, basil, and parm.


Shrimp Scampi


Succulent shrimp tossed over your choice of pasta with herbs and bread crumbs.

sub with ham, tomato and lettuce isolated on white background

Ham and Cheese Sandwich


Layers of ham and cheese on a bed of lettuce, tomato, onions, and topped with our house dressing.

Tasty chicken wings baked or grilled in sauce served on pan. Dark background. Horizontal.

Buffalo Chicken Wings


Breaded and then tossed in our secret sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and blue cheese dip.


Order your favorites from Michael's Pastaria in Nutley for your next party. Contact us today to cater your next event or corporate gathering. Email us at

Michael's Pastaria Nutley_Homepage (1)

About Us

Michael's Pastaria is a pizzeria located in Nutley N.J. Currently under new ownership as of March 2021 and serving the same original recipes, Michael's is your go-to pizza shop for delicious Italian dishes and more. We believe in serving our customers food with high-quality ingredients and delivering customer satisfaction on every meal. If for some reason we did not meet your expectations, please let us know.

We purchased Michael's because we love the Nutley community and loved their original thinny-thin pizza recipe. We're working hard to bring back what we know the Nutley community loved and trusted. Grab the family for a slice one evening or hire us to cater your next event. We offer in-room dining, pick-up, and delivery for your convenience. Come check out what the talk is about, we promise it won't disappoint.

We can't wait to meet you!

- Gerry & Don

Scroll to Top